Trouble With The Script.
Hold up a mirror to Brad Pitt’s MONEYBALL, you get Clint Eastwood’s TROUBLE WITH THE CURVE.
MONEYBALL (2011) told us the best way to draft major league baseball players is to study their stats on a computer and not rely on the disdainful opinions of crotchety old men. TROUBLE WITH THE CURVE tells us that despite the stats on a computer, you should rely on the disdainful opinions of crotchety old men.
Eastwood is crotchety old baseball scout Gus (basically playing the same character from GRAN TORINO – that is, a retired Harry who doesn’t realize he ain’t Dirty no more), who is sent out by a league who is starting to doubt his skills, scouting a batter named Bo Gentry (Joe Massingill). His sight is failing, so his league manager and friend (John Goodman) appeals to Gus’s estranged lawyer daughter Mickey (Amy Adams) to accompany Gus on the trip, to help him out. As a young girl, Mickey was dragged around the country by Gus, viewing so many baseball games that she is quite the expert herself, with a love of the game that is belied by her bodily immersion in lawyering.
On the trip, they meet fellow scout Johnny (Justin Timberlake), sent by the league to keep an eye on old Gus. Dumb, clichéd romance ensues between Johnny and Mickey (although we all know the more believable romance would have been between Timberlake and Clint, as all men are bound by God and Nature to worship Clint Eastwood).
Matthew Lillard is the league guy reliant on computer stats – and he’s made to look suitably ridiculous. That’s one complaint I have with the film as a whole: Randy Brown‘s screenplay paints each character in black and white, so that we know their fates from the outset. Lillard portrays a dork that stands by his statistics and wants to sign Bo Gentry, who has “trouble with the curve” ball – but Lillard will never see this reality by sitting at his computer screen. And Gentry comes off as a narcissistic asshole just aching to get signed for the money and the bitches. Let’s consult our PG-13 sports movie flow chart to see how Dork and Asshole fare in the final reel…Also, consult flow chart for outcome of estranged daughter brought on road trip – ah yes, to reconcile with dad by the end. Captain Obvious been whispering in your ear, Randy?Meanwhile, Johnny and Mickey take the requisite post-dinner evening walk through tree-lined streets with quaint stores, speaking softly and intimately. I… HATE this scene in movies! It’s shorthand for “new couple getting tentatively close” – but all men know the reality is actually a cultivation agenda that involves listening to her talk talk talk talk talk for hours about nothing, biding our time for Laying That Pipe. Consulting our PG-13 flow chart shows that Johnny and Mickey should follow this evening stroll with more stupid dialogue, maybe a non-naked swim in a night river, which leads to The Sex. Most movies portray The Sex with some slomo kissing silhouetted in front of curtains and maybe tasteful dark shots of a beast with two backs. But this movie cuts away after the non-naked swim. Fat chance we’ll see the rigorous pumping motions that sexual intercourse actually consists of, let alone Amy Adams’ fine porcelain plumpness. (I got no trouble with her curves at all.)
During their midnight swim, there is a sly baseball metaphor thrown in, as she tells Johnny to swim at a safe distance from her (because oh my gracious, how can a single girl trust the intentions of such a cad?). He swims closer and asks, “How’s this?” She replies, “Safe.” A little closer, “And this?” “Safe.” Just as we realize it’s a metaphor, we presume he’s stolen third base and sliding home. Underwater.
I am also uneasy with Eastwood falling back on his curmudgeon character too easily. I wish he didn’t feel like he was trapped in it. For the sake of his man-legacy, it seems as if this is Clint’s version of a “strong” character these days, or at least an obligation to the fans of his younger avenger characters. At that age, how naïve and pointless would one look if one were not cynical and mean-spirited? What’s an aging avenger to do?
We find that Gus’s meanness and his supposed “abandonment” of Mickey involve some wretchedly dark reasons. At one point, Gus says, “I’m just a broken down old man.” Wasn’t that Rourke’s exact line from THE WRESTLER? The subplot to humanize the curmudgeon – again, we see it coming a mile away.
And of course, the young pitcher they do end up signing is a nice quiet Mexican boy who doesn’t even realize how fast he can throw, and never got the shot because he was poor and blah blah – straight out of Screenwriting For Dummies.
TROUBLE is produced by Eastwood and directed by Robert Lorenz – and if you see many of Eastwood’s stylistic flourishes in this film, it’s because Lorenz has been Eastwood’s assistant director on innumerable Eastwood-directed films (ABSOLUTE POWER, TRUE CRIME, SPACE COWBOYS, including Oscar winner MILLION DOLLAR BABY).
Just one last baseball analogy: TROUBLE comes at us straight across home plate – no curveballs at all, just flat, straight pitches with predictable characters in predictable situations; no interesting plot developments, no irony, no twists, no real callbacks or payoffs.
Ironic that the movie itself has trouble with the curve.